The Brand Man Speaks

Free shipping becomes commodity offering vs benefit for holiday shoppers

For the past number of years, many millions of consumers had chosen to buy online vs in brick and mortar retail (Including on Black Friday) because of two reasons. First, no sales tax (in most states). Second, free shipping. Not all online sites had offered free shipping in the past. It might have required a minimum expenditure of say $50 but it did entice people to shop one place versus another.

This year it appears that "Free Shipping" has become a commodity offering. This means that it is offered by a much larger number of online only retailers and is being matched by many brick and mortar retailers on their online sites. It has in marketing parlance become "a price of entry" into the online shopping game. You have to offer it to survive and compete.

This is very good for consumers but could pose financial problems for retailers. Shipping costs are not inexpensive for retailers to absorb and could hurt profitability numbers at the end of the holiday season when all is tabulated.

One online retailer that appeals to young urban hipster types, Karmaloop.com, throws "free shipping" and percentage discounts out to its loyal buyers pretty frequently all year long. However, when you click through to final payment terms on your purchase you find they charge a $1.50 "handling" fee and don't see that has a shipping charge. I have expressed to the CEO that I feel this is a bit disceptive to consumers. The company's response has been they need to offset the huge costs of free shipping and this is how their bean counters told them to do it. Bad idea.

Personally, I have become a heavy Amazon.com shopper because of free shipping and very low cost two day and overnight shipping options as a "prime" member, (which costs $79 a year and is worth it in my opinion). I also have found from the comfort of my beach side lounge chair better deals on Amazon then some advertised Black Friday offerings at brick and mortar stores with the added bonus of no sales tax and no shipping fees. Pretty hard to beat without facing the vicious Black Friday crowds.

Watching out for you everyday.

Eli

 

LA Times "brand" story on Kardashian brand has follow up.

Here is the link to the follow up piece by writer Adam Tschorn. He explores my point of view.

Kardashian a Brand?

 

Watching out for you everday.

Eli

Black Friday moves to Turkey Day, Thanksgiving but will consumers respond positively to this move?

Getting a jump on Black Friday retail sales has become an obsession for millions of Americans. In the past few years most electronic and mass merchandiser retail concerns have opened their doors in the wee hours of the Friday after Thanksgiving. Some open at Midnight to lure shoppers to (supposedly) great bargains. Consumers have been seen lining up for hours to get into these special shopping events. But there maybe a backlash this holiday season.

This year a handful of retailers are pushing the time frame even earlier announcing they will open at 10pm on Thanksgiving. Some consumers think this is great news. However, a growing number are publicly saying they think stores opening in the evening of Thanksgiving Day is "crossing the line".

The line being crossed is the one which says making employees shorten their holiday family time to come to work is unfair, unreasonable and at one extreme a violation of workers rights. In many news articles over the past few days, thousands of consumers have expressed concern to full blown outrage that greedy retailers are forcing their employees (even with holiday pay) to give up time with family to work. Is this going to far? Are these outraged consumers right? Will retailers who open "too early" see a negative feedback in their sales? It is too early to tell but things are a brewing.

The "Occupy" rallies around the US have shown many Americans are fed up with corporate greed and the needs of the wealthy to make more and more money off the backs of the average guy. It is within this cultural paradigm shift that such a backlash against retailers forcing workers to work on holidays is getting much of its fuel.

It is a tricky line to cross because many retailers feel they must be competitive and lure shoppers in as quickly as possible to "snap up" the available holiday gift buying dollars especially in this on-going weak economy. Those retailers who will not open on Thanksgiving evening have expressed support for workers and their families but also acknowedge it could be a costly risk to lose valuable consumer sales.

Personally I cannot imagine being a part of this craziness and have found many of the same desirable items available from the comfort of one's home office online at comparable prices. But what is important here is the underlying voice of average Americans which has until the "Occupy" rallies been kind of quiet. I think it is very important for consumer products and service companies to be mindful of this increasingly vocal group and not to dismiss it as unimportant or minor in anyway. There will be changes in our culture that come out of this still undefined movement across the US. As of yet, as always when you are in the middle of a paradigm shift, it is unclear what kind or what magnitude of change will be forthcoming. Be rest assured, however, that an important shift is coming.

Watching out for you everyday.

Eli

Will quickie marriage (72 days) significantly damage Kardashian brand?

When I started to write this piece my own first question was, why does anybody care? Fortunately or unfortunately the Kardashian Klan have built a nice multi-million dollar business all about nothing or  better known as being famous for being (untalented) and famous.

However, there is enough interest in the question of whether Kim Kardashian had built a real brand or just a marketing fad, flash in the pan. In my opinion Kim has yet to "earn" rights to be called a true brand. Most of her antics are PR stunts (and let's not forget without a sex tape she would be absolutely nothing and we wouldn't be wasting our time on this) and not brand building efforts. Launching perfumes, apparel lines, getting paid to appear at clubs and bars and getting married on a reality show for $17Million doesn't not make a brand.

People are more fascinated with her nothingness as entertainment and not about a vision, a journey or some meaningful element to make people believe something she is offering has any real value. Her deal with Sears is a ridiculous one. Kardashian wouldn't be caught dead in a Sears unless she was picking up a paycheck for an appearance.

Now let's address this divorce business. Maybe had she made it past a year or even six months she would have some credibility. But this 72 day PR game wasn't love or a real marriage. It was a paid for "appearance" event in which she got paid in cash and in kind. Poor guy, hope he didn't really see anything in or have feelings for her. I also hope he is laughing to the bank for all this mess. Although he comes off more of an embarrassment to himself than she does because she is not in the least bit embarrassed about being a shill for anything or everything with a payday attached.

Now you might feel that Kardashian isn't much different than Paris Hilton. I beg to differ. Whether you liked it or not she had a particular way of being, a slogan ("That's hot") and a sense of style (not necessarily one you might like). She acted in a TV show that was somewhat entertaining. Kim Kardashian is a poor (woman's?) man's version of Hilton. Hilton had pedigree for her debutante behavior. Kardashian's father was an unknown until the O J Simpson case (like instant fame, "new" money). The Hiltons have been a fixture in America for years.

Will the business of Kardashian be hurt by this divorce? Likely. It exposed her as having nothing honest or real about herself and her so-called fans will probably feel cheated, lied to, deceived but quickly wake up from their delusion of fascination and become disgusted. No journey here just a young girl trying to make a buck. I would suggest Ms. Kardashian be careful not to spend all her quickly earned cash too fast because the gravy train is likely to end soon.

Watching out for you everyday.

Eli